U.S. Supreme Court Rules in Favor Religious Exemption to Discrimination Laws

Syndicate content Subscribe to the Blog
Posted on January 13, 2012 - 11:11am by brian.

In a landmark decision hailed by conservative Christians and advocates for religious liberty, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled Wednesday in favor of a Redford Township church's firing of a teacher.

The case centered on Cheryl Perich, who developed narcolepsy and sought to keep her job, which the church said she no longer could perform.

The court's ruling upheld the legal principle that houses of worship have what's called a ministerial exception, meaning they are exempt from some government laws, such as anti-discrimination laws. Such an exception allows the Catholic Church to ban women from being priests, for example.

In a unanimous decision, the court ruled that it was legal for Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School in Redford Township to fire Perich after she complained she was being discriminated against because of a disability.

"Praise God for giving the justices the wisdom to uphold the religious freedom enshrined in our Constitution," said the Rev. Paul Undlin of Hosanna-Tabor.

The case started in 2005 after the church tried to remove Perich because of her narcolepsy. Perich then said she was considering legal action. The church said Perich's threat was disruptive and violated a church policy to settle disputes internally.

Perich then filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, claiming her employment had been terminated in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act, a court filing said.

The U.S. government defended Perich; the church was represented by the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and professor Douglas Laycock of the University of Virginia School of Law.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan filed a brief in favor of Perich. "We are disappointed with today's result," spokesman Rana Elmir said.

The group Americans United for Separation of Church and State also expressed disappointment.

"Clergy who are fired for reasons unrelated to matters of theology -- no matter how capricious or venal those reasons may be -- have just had the courthouse door slammed in their faces," said the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, executive director of the group.

Contact Niraj Warikoo: 313-223-4792 or [email protected]

Comments

jordans shoes (not verified) says:

March 22, 2012 - 9:27pm

[b][url=http://www.comprabolsaslv.es/louis-vuitton-damier-geant-lienzo-C16.html]Louis Vuitton Damier Geant Lienzo[/url][/b] ground about a meter, down peacefully. [b][url=http://www.comprabolsaslv.es/louis-vuitton-monogram-lienzo-C18.html]Louis Vuitton Damier Monogram Lienzo[/url][/b] men with [b][url=http://www.comprabolsaslv.es/louis-vuitton-damier-grafito-lienzo-C17.html]Louis Vuitton Damier Grafito Lienzo[/url][/b] mental illness has been [b][url=http://www.comprabolsaslv.es/]Louis Vuitton bolsas[/url][/b] 3 years [b][url=http://www.comprabolsaslv.es/louis-vuitton-monogram-macassar-lienzo-C19.html]Louis Vuitton Monogram Macassar Lienzo[/url][/b] yesterday morning [b][url=http://www.comprabolsaslv.es/louis-vuitton-mensajero-bolsas-y-totes-C15.html]Louis Vuitton Mensajero Bolsas y Totes[/url][/b] 9.



jordans shoes (not verified) says:

March 22, 2012 - 9:33pm

grasp the psychology of others ,to jordan dwayne wade shoes grasp size 14 jordans cheap the scale air jordan size 15 air jordan shoes ;to nike shoes size 14 pay penny hardaway shoes for sale attention to.



Anonymous (not verified) says:

March 23, 2012 - 1:19am

In the Christian Louboutin shoes shop window, christian louboutin uk sale we see the urban population has been union for red shoes "peony" new variety shoes. According to the internal personnel introduces, christian louboutin shoes this year Christian Louboutin sales of women's shoes is likely to break through the usual 20%. Discount Christian Louboutin Shoes And they will also is due this year to set up a new Delhi between inner sole exhibition hall.

As is known to all, louboutins uk Christian Louboutin shoes series because of its extremely high of extremely fine heels, and bright red sole and world famous. In the past 20 years, its design has become the world's most famous vogue female choice. Now, this shoe giant also will appear again in India. http://www.louboutinny.com/



headphones (not verified) says:

March 26, 2012 - 4:02am

Good Ideals !Do these kind of insanity workout sound familiar?The photo sharing app/social monster beats headphones has grown to over 27 million active insanity users this month. Last week they announced their partnership with Coach outlet store online.With automotive design implemented in the design process, one Louis Vuitton UK detail we enjoyed was the guage -like dial which sits within a case inspired the aluminum wheel of a insanity dvd. The Vulcanised Fibreboard suitcase is handmade on original cheap coach purses machinery at the Globe-Louis Vuitton Outlet in

coach outlet online

, Hertfordshire. p90x was invented in USA and is formed from headphones by dr dre of specially bonded paper, coloured to monster headphones specification.The assurance of this natural anxiety cure insanity review is like a breath of ChaLean who have been having troubled thoughts, repeated anxiety attacks, lack of sleep, or are feeling like they are living on the Louis Vuitton UK Outlet. That is about to change. The insanity video has now launched a sign-up page for people that want to find out when the Monster Beats headphones by dr dre is going to launch and since first beats versions have already circulated, that should only be a matter of weeks.



coach factory outlet (not verified) says:

March 27, 2012 - 11:38pm

Summers ahead and coach factory outlet coach handbagshas started styling according to the weather. Summer coach purse
coach sunglass always have lots of colour and comfortable material to hold on.The Coach Cambridge Hobo Bags
Coach Carryalls Bags
Coach Crossbody Bags
Coach Multicolor Bags
Coach Shoulder Bags are always hot cake for the summers but what if this classic style meets with the modern glamour, definitely it creates a masterpiece. The Coach Signature Bags
Coach Totes Bags

Coach OP Art Handbags
Coach Backpacks Bags
Coach Business Bags
Coach Claire Bags
Coach Luggage Bags are always required in our wardrobes and this collection from Coach Shoulder Bags Canvas Balck
Coach Totes Bags Bowknot Brown
Coach Hobo Bags 5997
Coach Carryalls Bags 0021.jpg
Coach Claire Bags garnet
Coach Crossbody Bags ignitus black lilac that need with the luxurious touch by adding glitz to the casual concept. Coach Wallets 2011
Coach Checkbook Wallets
Coach Small Wallets
Coach Leather Wallets
Coach Wrist Wallets
Coach Jewelry
Coach Bangle
Coach Bracelet
Coach Earrings
Coach Necklace
Coach Jewelry Sets
Coach Shoes
Coach Boots
Coach Sneakers
Coach Sandals
are always pretty but summer collection by them have uniqueness in it which makes you look very different oncoach factory coach outlet.
http://www.2012coachoutlet.com/coach_blog/bags-handbags/coach-goods-sold...
http://www.2012coachoutlet.com/The-Biggest-Trends-of-Fall-2012:-Coach--n...
http://www.2012coachoutlet.com



WEDDINGSSALONONLINE.com (not verified) says:

October 24, 2012 - 12:18am

Nice comment on this page. WEDDINGSSALONONLINE.com



Blog

February 2012

September 2011

October 2010

May 2010

December 2009

October 2009

July 2009

June 2009

May 2009

April 2009

March 2007